In the same way my scrawling teenage penmanship has deteriorated through decades of digital document creation, my instincts to stop and save a game waned. I blame the rise of automatic saving, checkpoints, Xbox Quick Resume, and titles where the tension is so high that I feel compelled to save every two seconds just in case disaster strikes. Yet, I am fallible. I become complacent. Recently, I discovered an important lesson after significant time invested in the newly ported Pokémon FireRed on Nintendo's console: you must still manually hit save.
It had been years since I last played a pixel-art Pokémon adventure — never experiencing the GBA era, the Generation II titles may have been the most recent traditional Pokémon journey I played. Therefore, I was excited to pay twenty dollars for the sentimental journey to the Kanto region, and an attempt gathering those first 151 creatures. I quickly returned to the glory days. Across several nights, I was catching bugs, added Pikachu to my team, knocked out Brock with ease, took a chance on purchasing the useless fish from the Man at the Pokémon Center, and scaled Mt. Moon completely unconcerned.
The fatal flaw: I never saved my game! The idea simply didn't occur to me.
Jigglypuff will never be friends with that Mankey.
Everything went wrong during a session while I was taking a break from the game… and when my child grabbed the Switch for a swift 30 minutes of the newer Pokémon title instead, closing my game in the process. As we all know (something I temporarily forgot…) opening a new game on the console forces the closure of your current game. Your hours of play are only secured when an autosave triggers or if you remembered to save prior to changing games. My mistake.
The Progression of Saving Progress: From Manual to Automatic
It's fair to consider automatic saving, now so invisible most players barely notice it, as a true “next-generation” breakthrough. While PC text adventure Zork had one of the earliest save systems in gaming, the 1986 Zelda title is often credited as a landmark achievement because players no longer felt completely screwed by an in-game fail because of battery-backed saving on NES cartridges. Of course, the responsibility remained to save. (And following a single mistake), the lesson was learned for life. During the nineties, memory cards on consoles including the original PlayStation normalized the save process yet still fragile; failing to save (or losing a card) could erase countless hours. Titles such as Resident Evil even turned saving into a limited resource.
Today's automatic saving, the one that subdued my natural saving reflex my Pokémon adventure so effectively, took hold at the dawn of a new century. The first Halo introduced checkpoint saving as the Call of Duty series perfected the mechanic to smooth difficulty and reduce tedious replay. As game worlds expanded — and increasingly non-linear — developers solved the puzzle on constant background saves and, eventually, the ultimate convenience of picking up exactly where you left off.
A Franchise's Adaptation: From Conscious Choice to Unconscious Backup
Interestingly, this iconic franchise serves as a perfect mirror of that historical progression. For a long time, the act of saving your Pokémon journey was a deliberate choice: fans were taught to manually record their data before closing their device. Starting with Pokémon Sword and Shield for the Nintendo Switch, the games added an autosave feature (at first as a toggleable option), representing a substantial design shift for one of gaming’s most tradition-bound franchises.
I can admit failure: Years of playing Breath of the Wild and modern Mario games totally eroded my manual save reflex. I still know better under specific circumstances — I refuse to chance quitting during a run in a challenging indie title even knowing it has a robust save system — but whether it’s been too long since I sank time classic gaming mechanics, or I'm simply pampered, it didn’t even occur to me to manually save when I stopped playing. Seven-year-old me would never have fumbled to this degree.
The Result: Starting From Scratch
I have not opened FireRed after my data loss incident. When I loaded it back up and discovered my team consisted solely of the beginning Squirtle, my motivation evaporated. My personal status: Burned.
Maybe I’ll go back… or perhaps I'll remain in the countless modern titles available now which gently presume I am incapable of manual saving. However, my love for retro gaming remains alive. When I can pry my daughter away from the modern, auto-saving Pokémon game, we’ve been tag-teaming a collection of classic Bomberman games. Those early SNES games skipped saving altogether opting instead for cryptic character strings. So, even if I blow myself up, all is not lost. That, at least, is reassuring.